When watching a blu-ray rental:

Tuesday, June 7, 2011

Oppo BDP-93, Denon DBP-2012UDCI, Samsung BD-D6700, or Oppo BDP-95

Which one should I buy?  Over the last 3 weeks I have been struggling with which one of these fine blu-ray players I should buy next?

My music/movies split is pretty much 50/50.  My number one and two choices are Denon DBP-2012UDCI and Oppo BDP-93 respectively because both are Universal Players and will play all formats including SACD, DVD-Audio, and HDCD.

Here are the Pros and Cons of these players and you can help me decide which one I should go with by taking the survey above.  I don't care about streaming capabilities so those are not listed.

#1 Denon DBP-2012UDCI ($899):
Stay Tuned for my upcoming review
My first universal player was a Denon DVD player DVD-2910 which I purchased back in 2003 for $600 from Crutchfield.  I loved that player because of its excellent Audio and Video capabilities.  No player has remained in my system longer than the 2910.  I sold it (big mistake) in 2007 to pay for the PS3 (fatty) which is about to beat the 2910 in terms tenure in my system this October.  I have also owned a host of other blu-ray players (between $400 and $1000) since the format was first introduced back in 2007 including the top of the line Pioneer Elites, Sony, Samungs, and Panasonics.

PROS:
-3D, Universal Player (SACD, DVD-Audio, and HDCD)
-BURR-BROWN PCM-1795 192kHz/32-bit audio digital-to-analog converters.  Same DACs as the Onkyo TX-NR5007 which I have first hand experience with and loved.
-Independent Block Construction isolates electronic circuits for faithful playback of audio and video tracks
-Direct Mechanical Ground Construction suppresses vibration and ensures high-quality sound and video
-Standard definition content from DVDs is deinterlaced and scaled up to HD via Anchor Bay Technologies VRS ultra performance ABT-2015 processor

CONS:
-no built-in Wi-Fi
-The front plate is plastic
-Anchor Bay is good but I prefer Marvell's video processor with Qdeo™ technology
-Previous Generation Denon's have been a little sluggish and slow with firmware issues

#2 Oppo BDP-93 ($499):
Oppo has made quite a name for themselves since they first burst on the scene with their upconvert DVD players in the mid 2000's.  I personally have not tried an Oppo yet and have always been curious.  I chose the Pioneer Elite BDP-23FD over the Oppo BDP-83 last year after reading Tom Norton's Blu-ray shootout on UltimateAVmag.com, in which he compared the video on the 23FD to Marantz 7004 and the Oppo 83.

PROS:
-Fast Load times
-Solid Build
-3D, Universal Player (SACD, DVD-Audio, and HDCD)
-Plays FLAC, WAV, and other media through USB and eSATA.
-Dual HDMI, but only HDMI-1 uses Marvell processing while HDMI-2 uses the Mediatek decoder.  
-Wi-Fi (with provided USB adaptor)
-Qdeo by Marvell
-Best Customer Service in the World

CONS:
-Cirrus Logic DACs.  Not a fan
-I think I have seen multiple firmware versions since the release.  Makes me wonder a bit

#3 Samsung BD-D6700 ($399):
This one is interesting.  I just read a review of this player in the July 2011 issue of the Hometheater magazine by Kris Deering.   He said and I quote "the BD-D6700 provided all the picture and audio quality I get from even Oppo BDP-95.  Images were razor sharp, with jaw-dropping levels of detail and dimensionality.  The audio experience was second to none."  This is what has made me add the BD-D6700 to this list.  Pretty impressive! 

PROS:
-Superfast load times
-Gorgeous Looks
-3D
-Dual HDMI,
-built-in Wi-Fi
-2D to 3D upconversion

Cons:
-Samsung? I do not like Samsung Blu-ray players
-If you are looking for solid construction, look elsewhere.
-no name DACs and Video Processor
-not a Universal player
-no Analog outputs
-subpar DVD-upconversion
-Did I mention it is a Samsung

#4 Oppo BDP-95 ($999):
Review and First Impressions coming soon as I just purchased the BDP-95.  Stay tuned!
Pretty much the same as the BDP-93 but with upgraded Audio Section for 2-channel and Multi-Channel analog audio.  The upgraded audio is available in the form of ES9018 SABRE 32-bit Reference DACs.  That is true high-end Turf. 

PROS:
-SABRE32 Reference Audio DAC delivers an impressive DNR (Dynamic Range) of up to 135dB and THD+N of -120dB. 
-Toroidal Power Supply for Analog
-XLR Balanced Stereo Output
-Competes with players that cost 4 times or sometimes 10 times as much, e.g. (AYRE DX_5 $9,950)

CONS:
-Hometheater magazine mentioned BDP-95 and Samsung BD-D6700 in the same sentence and stated that the digital Audio and Video performance of the Samsung was just as good as the Oppo BDP-95.  Things that make you go hmmm!

7 comments:

  1. Still rocking my original 60gb PS3!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Nice. The original ones were better than the new Slim ones.

    ReplyDelete
  3. keep the votes coming. it is a tie between the Denon and the Oppo BDP-95

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks to everyone for voting on the poll. Samsung got no votes but it is a tie between the Denon and BDP-95. I am going to go with the Denon.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I just purchased the Oppo BDP-95. I will be posting my first impressions soon on this blog. Stay tuned!

    ReplyDelete
  6. I'm still using my 1st generation PS3 too. Mostly because it also gives me Hulu and Netflix as well.

    cheers,
    JD
    http://www.denonhometheater.com

    ReplyDelete
  7. i still dont know what to buy.

    ReplyDelete

Do you prefer 2-channel or Multichannel music?